Showing posts with label Schwartz. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Schwartz. Show all posts

Monday, January 22, 2001

In the Family Way by Lynne Sharon Schwartz

I want to talk to you this morning about a new book by Lynne Sharon Schwartz, entitled, In the Family Way: An Urban Comedy. Schwartz has been a favorite author of mine ever since I read her most important novel, Disturbances in the Field. She also wrote one of the best coming-of-age, leaving-childhood-behind novels I’ve ever read, entitled Leaving Brooklyn, a rich novel about how hard it is to in some sense transcend or escape family, hometown, childhood religion. Of course, she is also well aware that we cannot literally transcend our histories, that we carry them with us forever and that even reaction and attempted overthrow of such influences is, itself, an acting out of our historicity. Still, the attempt to step outside and look at how we are influenced by culture and family is, according to Schwartz, crucial to freeing ourselves. It is understanding how these influences determine us that in some sense frees us.

Finally, before getting to her recent novel, let me remind you of one other of her books, Ruined by Reading: A Life in Books, the manifesto of a reader that should strike a chord in any dedicated, lifetime reader; it’s funny and insightful as well as providing a kind of justification for reading as an end in itself. And as a kind of continuation of that book, there is a brand new collection of essays, Face to Face, that will delight any Schwartz fan.

In the Family Way is about a modern kind of extended family living in New York City. Billed on its cover as a comedy of manners, I think, instead, that it is a very serious look at what families might become. Ursula Le Guin, who is also sited on the jacket cover, says that Schwartz has proved Tolstoy wrong in this book, that “All happy families are not alike. Her novel is about a happy family that is totally unlike any other family you have read about.” I think Le Guin is just right; Schwartz wants to tell us in this book what families here and now could be like. She understands that divorce is much more common now than in the past, and that there are more and more children who are in what get called broken families. What Schwartz wants to tell us about is a way of not breaking families in spite of the fact of separation and divorce.

In this often funny but also very serious novel, we have a family that consists of many members who are connected in many ways. The grandmother, who remembers very well her youth in The Young Socialist League where she met and married her first love Mickey, actually owns the apartment building in which they all live, but it is her daughter Bea who really runs things. Bea’s first husband, Roy, also lives in the building, but not with Bea, nor with his second wife Serena. Instead, Roy lives with his third wife, Lisa, who is pregnant with his fifth child, and yes, they, too, live in the building. Bea lives with her two children, Sara (who has become Shimmer), and Danny. Her other two children, who are not hers biologically, but, rather, the biological offspring of her husband, Ray, and a Viet Namese woman, Lien, now deceased, have been raised by her for most of their lives, but are now grown and gone. Bea’s lover, Dimitri, is also the apartment’s super. Oh, and I forgot to mention, Serena still lives in the building, but now she lives with May, Bea’s artist sister, and Serena, too, is pregnant, that is, in the family way. But you will have to read the book to see just how this has come about.

So, is this a chaotic household, filled with seething jealousies and dysfunctional units? Well, there are jealousies, and there are problems, but under the benign guidance and wisdom of Bea, I would call this a very well adjusted and, yes, happy family. One of the things I find oddest about divorce is not the separation itself, which is so often so very good for the two people who have been married (and, while married, found ways to daily diminish each other in the name of love and duty); no, it is not the separation that surprises me, but the bitterness and hatred left behind. As if the divorce somehow proves that the two never loved each other, never had anything in common, that it all had to be some horrible mistake and lie. No doubt, there are divorces that are escapes from a kind of daily hell, but it is also so often the case that the people involved seem to think they must learn to hate the other, turn from each other totally, in order to justify the separation. And if there are children involved who somehow still love both parents, well ... so much the worse for them, since they must deal daily with the venom and hatred that stands between the two people they most love.

When Roy announces to Bea that he has fallen in love with a client (Roy is a therapist), wanting Bea somehow to forgive him professionally as well as personally, she does just that. Never mind that she has a bit of a thing going with Dimitri already, making Roy’s ‘abandonment’ somewhat easier. What she sees clearly is that Roy really loves his children, and that they really love and need him. That they will share custody is never in question, and if living in the same neighborhood would be a good thing for the children, same schools, same friends, etc., well then why not live in the same building?
Right now we need to plan how to manage this. We’re not going to be angry, or fight over money, or the kids, or all the things people do. We’re going to behave like a family, as we always have. I’ll talk to this woman—what’s her name anyway?

“Serena.”

“This Serena, and we’ll work it out. We’ll explain to her that this isn’t a connection we can break off just like that. It wasn’t only sex between us. We have a life together. She’ll understand, if she’s a reasonable person. She didn’t want to end her own marriage, did she? You had to persuade her. It’ll be better for her too, not having to deal with a furious ex-wife. Believe me, this is the way to go. Look, Roy, it’s starting to get light. I really must get some sleep.” She slid down under the quilt.

“I can’t believe you’re rolling over and going to sleep after this. This is your marriage breaking up.”

“Yes.” she murmured, but life goes on. Or so they say.
Of course, you can see that this is quite a set-up for humor, and I quite understand why reviewers were caught up with the comedy side of the book, but I am convinced that this novel is not primarily a comedy, nor is it a critique of modern relationships and a call to return to traditional values. Instead, I think Schwartz is very seriously trying to tell us about how we might live in a changing world, how we might be able to salvage the very best parts of committed relationships without also buying into what is worst about them. Same sex relationships, committed relationships without marriage, mutual and friendly dissolving of what have been good relationships, perpetuating strong relationships even when the living together ends—all of these things are possible, and all good ways of preserving family in the very best sense of family. Separating without hating, without giving the lie to the past, without forcing children into impossible choices of whom to love and whom to reject.

Schwartz, herself, has lived a long life of balancing the needs and demands of family life with the need for space and privacy and a place to work. And it is obvious from all of her work that she does not regret it. Yes, one needs a room of one’s own, but she has found fulfillment in her children, her mate. She loves to observe them as well as to immerse herself in their lives. Unlike writers like May Sarton who have found that they must choose between love/family and creativity, Schwartz has found room for both, and is convinced that each nourishes the other.

I think this is a rich and serious book. There are lots of characters, and you may need to read into it a hundred pages or so before you really find yourself, but give it a chance. Try to read it in a sustained way, and I think you will find, as I did, that Schwartz has lots to tell us about how we can live and love here and now

Monday, November 10, 1997

Ruined by Reading: A Life in Books by Lynne Sharon Schwartz

I want to talk to you this morning about one of a number of wonderful writers who revealed the world to me this summer. But unlike almost all the books I have talked to you about before, this is a book about being a reader. The authors name is Lynne Sharon Schwartz; she so impressed me when I read her masterwork, Disturbances in the Field, that at first opportunity I bought all of her books, and then reading as she thinks we ought, greedily and isolated, one after the other, I read up her life’s work. But it is her last book, written in 1995 and not fiction at all, that I want to talk about today. Its title is Ruined by Reading: A Life in Books.

All of us are asked, too often, what it is that we do. When I am brave enough to answer honestly, I say that I am a reader—that I read. The reactions I get range from amused to perplexed to enraged. Tough enough for writers and artists to be taken seriously, but though it may seem sad to many that some people have such unprofitable addictions, still one can be a writer or artist—perhaps an ill-chosen life, but a real one. But to claim to be a reader! Might as well say time-waster, idler. “Come on, really, do you mean you are a teacher or aspiring writer?” Though I happen to be a teacher as well as a reader, I sometimes try to persevere. “No, I am a reader.”

No wonder when I ran across this little volume of autobiographical essay, I was instantly intrigued. Though I seldom aspire to being a writer (and am much more interested in what I can read than what I can write), here was a book that I wished I had written—one that I had thought of writing, though certainly not with the wit and skill that Schwartz has. Here is a reader who boldly announces her addiction to works of the imagination, and who admits, proclaims: “With barely a twinge of conscience, I hurl down what bores me or doesn’t give what I crave: ecstasy, transcendence, a thrill of mysterious connection.” Should one read in accordance with duty or want? And again, she answers as I have so often answered, ‘follow your wants.’

I noticed early on that when I had a piece of duty-reading (or writing) that stood between me and reading for pleasure, I often simply stopped reading! So, in graduate school, I made what I thought was a bold move; I would consider all reading good, all a part of my work. It worked like magic as my reading increased and increased in such a way that I even did more duty-reading almost as accident or afterthought. As Schwartz says, “There are after all so many delectable books in the world.”

But, you might be thinking (and we readers so often hear), reading is an escape from living. Her answer is bold: “It didn’t replace living; it infused it, till the two became inextricable, like molecules of hydrogen and oxygen in a bead of water.” And continuing, “How are we to spend our lives, anyway? That is the real question. We read to seek the answer, and the search itself, the task of a lifetime, becomes the answer.”

In only one way is her answer less radical than mine. Still, in spite of the fact that she writes for a living, that she must read in order to write, she cannot bring herself to read in the morning.
Never mornings—even to one so self-indulgent, it seems slightly sinful to wake up and immediately sit down with a book—afternoons only now and then. In daylight I would pay what I owed the world. Reading was the reward, a solitary, obscure, nocturnal reward. It was what I got everything else (living) out of the way in order to do.
Sinner that I am, I read first thing and all day, everyday (when I have the chance); I use my very best energy, morning energy, for what I consider my important vocation, and I urge my students to do the same (when schedule allows such a luxury). Read as if it is the most important thing you will do all day! As she says, “What I liked was having a book happen to me.” Yes, and the way to do that is to clear the decks, to see reading as self-justifying, as worthy.

I cant tell you how much I feel I have gotten from this author, about reading, about writing, about living. “...writing seems less a craft than a quality of mind and discernment, a rarefied focusing.” Yes, a focusing that allows some wonderfully gifted people to really see, to dis-cover, to bring out of concealment. Schwartz is like an american Iris Murdoch. To read what she has to say about whether it is best, finally, to read from duty or from want is to be at once amused and awakened. She is so wonderfully bright, so witty, her words so flowing and water-like, but always with a serious current.

Let me touch on just a couple more themes she raises and that I have thought of so often in my life as a reader. Why, I have often asked myself, am I so compelled to read living authors, so convinced that the academic preference for (usually dead) white males is such a profound mistake. Is it just a taste for the new, the modern? No, says Schwartz.
The pressure to read the living is moral as well as social. We must know our own times, understand what is happening around us. The more purposeful a writer is, the more her work defines a particular connection to her time and surroundings. Or, if defines sounds a bit deadly, lets say shows, for no writer consciously set out to do it (or does so at her peril). The connection is evident in the writing to the degree that it is strong in the writer. If she does not feel context—time, place, spirt—pressing in on her like humidity, the work will be ephemeral and self-reverential, brittle as a fallen leaf.
Schwartz takes up another of my favorite claims: good reading is not necessarily fast reading. Indeed, it may be true that the better the book, the slower it needs to be read. Reading is not, if you are a real reader, killing time. Indeed, “Killing time is to living what Woods speed-reading is to reading.” And speed reading is not reading at all, but eye exercises! It is a blasphemous way to read. And for all those who reject books because they are too serious, even depressing, not happy, Schwartz has little patience. One who cannot be deeply pleased by reading a depressing book is not a reader at all, he/she might as well turn to television, which Schwartz refers to as “one of the devils ploys to buy our souls.” The desire to read, really read, must also be the desire to have the world revealed to us, and the world is not a happy place.

Reading is, indeed, as I have always thought, one of the genuine entrances into the larger world, the social world, the political world—away from the merely conventional and conservative, and its thrust is finally away from self (no matter how selfish it may seem to be curled up with a book).